Key takeaways
- Never hand over your car until you have confirmed the payment is in your bank account.
- Be cautious of buyers who send unexpected links, request refunds or ask you to pay fees to receive money.
- Keep communication in writing and avoid sharing personal or financial information that is not required for the sale.
- Check for warning signs such as new profiles, unusual payment requests or pressure to complete the sale quickly.
- If you think you have been scammed, stop the transaction, contact your bank and report the incident promptly.
What are online marketplace scams?
Online marketplace scams are fraudulent schemes used by people posing as genuine buyers or sellers on platforms such as Facebook Marketplace and Gumtree. When selling a car online, scams may involve fake payments, overpayment requests, phishing links, attempts to steal personal information or even vehicle theft.
We asked some of our buying experts about automotive scams and what they recommend to help remain safe and enjoy a smooth sale. While we are sales professionals, our advice comes from personal experience. If you have been scammed, it is important to contact local police and ScamWatch to rectify your individual situation.

Skip the risks of selling through online marketplaces
Avoid managing marketplace listings, dealing with unknown buyers, and handling payment concerns. Sell your car directly to 1800 Car Buyers with a simple, secure process.
Common scams to watch for when selling a car online
Scammers may use different tactics to target people selling cars through online marketplaces. Some focus on fake or misleading payments, while others try to obtain personal information or direct sellers to fraudulent websites. Knowing how these common marketplace scams work can help you recognise the warning signs before you lose money or information.
.png)
Fake payment scams
A scammer may claim they have paid for your car and send a fake transfer receipt, email or screenshot as proof. They may then pressure you to hand over the vehicle before the payment has actually cleared.
Always check your bank account to ensure the funds are available before handing over your car or completing the sale.
PayID scams
PayID scams often involve fake emails, texts or messages claiming you need to pay a fee or upgrade your account before you can receive money. Be cautious if a marketplace buyer asks for your email address or sends instructions that appear to come directly from PayID.
As NAB Executive, Group Investigations and Fraud, Chris Sheehan explained via Drive, “PayID will never send you an email, text or message directly as your bank registers and manages PayIDs.”
Overpayment and refund scams
In an overpayment scam, a buyer may claim they accidentally transferred more than the agreed sale price and ask you to refund the difference. The original payment or proof of payment may be fake, leaving you out of pocket if you send money back.
Confirm that the full payment is in your bank account before sending any money or proceeding with the sale.
Phishing and fake vehicle report scams
Some scammers may send a link to a website claiming you need to purchase a vehicle report or provide additional information before they will buy your car. These websites may be designed to collect your personal or payment details.
Avoid clicking suspicious links or providing sensitive information through unfamiliar websites.
Warning signs of an online marketplace scam
Marketplace scams can take different forms, but there are often warning signs before money, personal information or your vehicle is at risk. Be cautious if a potential buyer behaves unusually, makes the transaction unnecessarily complicated or pressures you to act quickly.
- The buyer asks you to pay a fee or send money before you can receive their payment.
- They send unexpected links for payments, vehicle reports or account verification.
- They provide a payment receipt, but the money does not appear in your bank account.
- They try to move the conversation to another messaging platform almost immediately.
- Their social media profile is new, has little activity or does not appear to match their details.
- They ask for personal or financial information that is not needed to complete the sale.
- Their explanation about payment changes or becomes confusing as the sale progresses.
If something about a buyer or transaction feels suspicious, you do not have to continue with the sale. Waiting for another genuine buyer may help you avoid getting scammed.
How to stay safe when selling on an online marketplace
Selling your car through an online marketplace can involve dealing with people you do not know. Taking a few precautions with communication, payments, personal information and inspections can help reduce the risks involved in a private sale.
- 01
Keep communication in writing
Keep your conversations with potential buyers in writing where possible so you have a record of what has been discussed. Be cautious if someone immediately tries to move the conversation to another platform or sends suspicious links.
- 02
Confirm the payment yourself
Do not rely solely on screenshots, receipts or messages provided by a buyer. Check your own bank account and confirm the money has arrived before handing over your keys or completing the sale.
- 03
Protect your personal information
Only share the information needed to complete the sale. Avoid clicking on unfamiliar links or providing personal, banking or account details when a buyer cannot clearly explain why they need them.
- 04
Arrange inspections and test drives safely
Meet potential buyers in a public location, such as a shopping centre car park. Before a test drive, obtain the buyer's phone number and check their driver's licence. Where possible, do not allow an unfamiliar buyer to test drive your vehicle alone.
What should you do if you think you’ve been scammed?
If you think you’ve been scammed while selling your car online, act quickly to protect your money, personal information and accounts. The right steps will depend on what information you shared and whether any money was transferred.
- 01
Contact your bank immediately
If you sent money or shared banking details, contact your bank as soon as possible. Explain what happened so they can advise you on securing your accounts and any steps available for the transaction.
- 02
Secure your online accounts
Change the passwords for any accounts that may have been compromised. If you entered personal or financial information into a suspicious website, review other accounts that use the same or similar login details.
- 03
Report the scam
Report the incident to local police where appropriate, and ScamWatch. Keep copies of messages, payment details, profiles and other information related to the scam to support your report.
- 04
Protect your personal information
If you shared sensitive personal information, take steps to secure any affected identification or accounts. This may include replacing compromised cards or identification documents and monitoring your accounts for suspicious activity.
Sell your car without dealing with marketplace buyers
Selling through an online marketplace can mean managing listings, enquiries, payment checks and meetings with potential buyers. With 1800 Car Buyers, you can sell your vehicle through a straightforward process without navigating private marketplace sales.
Clear, upfront quotes
Receive a competitive quote based on your vehicle details and current market data, so you know what is being offered before proceeding.
Secure Osko payments
Once the sale is finalised, payment is securely processed via Osko directly into your bank account.
Simple digital process
Complete the key steps digitally without creating marketplace listings or negotiating with multiple private buyers.
Fast vehicle collection
Once everything is arranged, we can organise fast collection of your vehicle for a convenient end to the selling process. You can also explore our recent purchases to see examples of vehicles we've bought across Australia.
Frequently asked questions
Here are some common questions about identifying scams, recognising red flags and staying safer when using online marketplaces to sell a car.
What are the red flags of a scammer during a car sale?
Watch for a buyer who creates a sense of urgency, sends suspicious payment links, asks you to overpay or refund money, or requests unnecessary personal information. Another red flag is receiving supposed proof of a bank transfer when the money has not appeared in your account.
How can I identify scams when using online marketplaces?
When using online marketplaces such as Gumtree and Facebook Marketplace, check whether the buyer's profile and messages appear genuine. Be cautious of unusual payment methods, unexpected links and requests for sensitive information. Always confirm payment through your own bank before completing the sale.
What should I do if I think I'm getting scammed?
Stop communicating with the suspected scammer and do not send money or hand over your car. If banking information or money is involved, contact your bank immediately. Keep records of the conversation and report the scam to the relevant authorities.
How can I protect myself from scams when selling items online?
When selling an item such as a car, keep communication in writing, protect your personal details and use secure payment methods. Check that the money is in your account rather than relying on payment screenshots, and avoid unfamiliar links or requests involving gift cards or cryptocurrency.
Where can Australians report fraud from an online marketplace?
Australians can report scams to the Australian Government's Scamwatch service. Depending on the type of scam, you may also need to contact your bank, local police or IDCARE if your personal information has been compromised and there is a risk of identity theft.


